Contact: Brenon Daly
With Wall Street continuing to look like forbidding territory to most IPO candidates, where are money-burning companies going to restock their treasury? Increasingly, hedge funds and mutual fund giants are providing, collectively, the hundreds of millions of dollars in financing that might have otherwise come through IPOs.
This, of course, isn’t an entirely new phenomenon. But we can’t recall a time that has seen more late-stage funding than the just-completed second quarter. Okta, Atlassian, New Relic, Pure Storage and others all drew in financing during the past three months from investment firms that have historically only purchased shares in public companies. In many ways, it’s a wonder that it took the recent chill in the IPO market to spur this ‘crossover’ activity to new levels. (We’ll have a full look at the recent IPO market – as well as the other exit, M&A – in our report on Q2 activity available later today on 451 Research.)
From the money managers’ perspective, these investments in private companies offer a bit of portfolio diversification, as well as the opportunity to outpace the returns of the broader equity market, which has registered a mid-single-digit percentage gain so far in 2014. And on the other side of the investment, the late-stage companies stand to receive tens of millions of dollars from a single investor without all the SEC rigmarole and other public company exposure.
Further, with billions of dollars to put to work, the mutual funds and hedge fund giants haven’t shown themselves to be as ‘price sensitive’ as other traditional late-stage funders. (The discrepancy between valuations of illiquid private shares and freely traded public stock stands out even more now, as new issues are being discounted heavily in order to make it public at all. For instance, Five9 stock has never even reached the minimum price the company and its underwriters thought it should be worth, and currently trades at just 3.5 times this year’s revenue. Meanwhile, MobileIron shares have dropped almost uninterruptedly since the company’s IPO, falling back to only slightly above their offer price. MobileIron is currently valued at only about half the level that a direct rival received when it sold earlier this year.)
Like life, markets are cyclical and IPOs will undoubtedly come back into favor on Wall Street at some point. But in the meantime, many late-stage companies are calling on the big-money investors to keep the lights on. We would include Box in that category. The high-profile company, which has been on file publicly since March, has found its path to the public market a rather rocky one. Having already raised more than $400m in backing, we could well imagine the money-burning collaboration software vendor crossing off an IPO (at least for now) and going back to a crossover investor for cash later this summer.
For more real-time information on tech M&A, follow us on Twitter @451TechMnA.